📱Test our Android app — free beta!Join Beta GroupYou'll receive the install link by email after joining.

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.


—rti-pmay-application-stuck [2026/07/22 15:48] (current) – created - external edit 127.0.0.1
Line 1: Line 1:
 +{{htmlmetatags>metatag-keywords=(rti, pmay, application, stuck, RTI Act, RTI Wiki)&metatag-description=(Stuck PMAY application? Make the housing cell answer with on — Sunita applied for PMAY-G in her gram panchayat in Bihar in October. The Sarpanch took…)}}
 +
 +
 +====== Stuck PMAY application? Make the housing cell answer with one RTI ======
 +
 +{{ :social:auto:rti-pmay-application-stuck.webp?direct&1200 |Social auto rti pmay application stuck}}
 +
 +
 +
 +<WRAP center round info 95%>
 +**Quick Reply:** Stuck PMAY application? Make the housing cell answer with on — Sunita applied for PMAY-G in her gram panchayat in Bihar in October. The Sarpanch took…
 +</WRAP>
 +
 +<WRAP info>
 +**Short version.** If your **PMAY-G** (rural) or **PMAY-U** (urban) application has been stuck on **AwaasSoft / Awaas+** for months — "Application submitted", "Pending verification", "Awaiting sanction" — a one-page RTI to the **PIO of your DRDA** (rural) or **Municipal Corporation Housing Cell** (urban), with **₹10 fee**, legally forces a written reply within **30 days** under §7(1) of the RTI Act 2005. This guide gives you the template, the statute, and the case law.
 +</WRAP>
 +
 +===== A real story you'll recognise =====
 +
 +Sunita applied for PMAY-G in her gram panchayat in Bihar in October. The Sarpanch took her papers, said //"sanction one month mein aa jaayega"//. Six months passed. Awaas+ portal said //"Application submitted — pending verification"//. The Block Development Officer's office said //"upar se list nahi aayi"//.
 +
 +She filed an RTI with help from a paralegal. **Eighteen days later** the BDO's office wrote back: her file had been pending at the panchayat secretary's desk because of a missing geo-tagged photo. The reply also disclosed that her application had been **deprioritised below five non-eligible names** — which she could now appeal in writing.
 +
 +This is the most common PMAY use of RTI in India — and it works because **PMAY-G is administered under the Awaas+ scheme by the Ministry of Rural Development** with district-level execution by the **DRDA**, and **PMAY-U is administered by the Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs** with execution by the **ULB Housing Cell** — both of which have designated PIOs.
 +
 +===== What an RTI to PMAY does =====
 +
 +  - **It enters a register.** Under §5(1) RTI Act, every public authority (DRDA, ULB) must designate a PIO. Your RTI gets a serial number and a 30-day clock starts (§7(1)).
 +  - **A specific officer becomes personally liable.** Failure to reply in 30 days = **deemed refusal** under §7(2), and §20(1) allows the Information Commission to fine the PIO ₹250/day (capped at ₹25,000) from their own salary.
 +  - **Your file becomes traceable.** The PIO must locate your Awaas+ application file to answer your questions. In the process they almost always find the actual block — missing document, wrong panchayat data, or an internal scoring issue — and tell you what's needed to clear it.
 +
 +The result is statistical: **most stuck-PMAY RTIs get a substantive reply within 25 days**, and many resolve the application itself in the same window because the officer has to physically retrieve the file.
 +
 +===== The statute — what you can ask, what they must answer =====
 +
 +==== Your right to information (RTI Act 2005) ====
 +
 +  * **§6(1)** — Any citizen may, on ₹10 fee, request information from a public authority. DRDA and ULB are public authorities under §2(h).
 +  * **§7(1)** — The PIO **shall** dispose of the request within **30 days**.
 +  * **§7(2)** — Failure within 30 days = deemed refusal, opens immediate appeal.
 +  * **§4(1)(b)(xii)** — A public authority must **suo motu publish** the particulars of recipients of subsidies (i.e. PMAY beneficiary lists). If your locality's list is not published — that itself is a compliance failure you can flag.
 +
 +==== PMAY-G specific provisions ====
 +
 +  * **PMAY-G Operational Guidelines 2016 (latest revision 2024)** — issued by Ministry of Rural Development. Sets the SECC 2011 / Awaas+ eligibility filter, scoring, and sanction timeline (target: 12-15 months from selection).
 +  * **Awaas+ portal** — beneficiary registration, geo-tagging, instalment release, completion verification.
 +  * **District / Block / Panchayat hierarchy** — DRDA at district, BDO at block, Panchayat Secretary at village.
 +
 +==== PMAY-U specific provisions ====
 +
 +  * **PMAY-U Mission Document 2015 (revised 2022)** — Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs.
 +  * **CLSS / BLC / AHP / ISSR verticals** — different beneficiary tracks.
 +  * **State Level Sanctioning and Monitoring Committee (SLSMC)** — sanctions DPRs.
 +  * **ULB Housing Cell** — applicant-facing PIO.
 +
 +==== What the housing cell can refuse — the §8(1)(j) line ====
 +
 +  * **Allowed:** your own application, your file noting, the panchayat / ULB beneficiary list, sanction status, scoring details, reasons for delay.
 +  * **Not allowed (without strong public interest):** another applicant's Aadhaar, bank account number, full address. The Supreme Court in //Girish Ramchandra Deshpande v. CIC, (2013) 1 SCC 212// held personal information of others is §8(1)(j) exempt.
 +
 +===== A copy-ready RTI to your DRDA / ULB =====
 +
 +Print this on plain paper. No stamp, no notary needed.
 +
 +<code>
 +To,
 +The Public Information Officer (PIO),
 +Office of the District Rural Development Agency / Municipal Corporation Housing Cell,
 +[Full address — find it on awaassoft.nic.in or pmay-urban.gov.in]
 +
 +Subject: Application under §6(1) of the Right to Information Act, 2005 —
 +status of my PMAY-G / PMAY-U application
 +
 +Sir/Madam,
 +
 +Under §6(1) of the Right to Information Act, 2005, I request the following
 +information regarding my pending PMAY application:
 +
 +   Applicant name : [Your full name]
 +   Father's name  : [As on Aadhaar]
 +   Awaas+ App. No : [from awaassoft.nic.in / pmay-urban.gov.in]
 +   Application date: DD-MM-YYYY
 +   Block / Panchayat: [Block, Panchayat, Village]
 +   PMAY type      : [PMAY-G / PMAY-U]
 +   Vertical (if U): [BLC / CLSS / AHP / ISSR]
 +
 +Information sought:
 +
 +   1. The current status and exact stage of processing of the above
 +      application as on the date of disposal of this RTI.
 +
 +   2. The name and designation of the officer / dealing assistant
 +      currently holding my application file.
 +
 +   3. The date(s) on which my application moved between sections
 +      (Panchayat → Block → DRDA), in chronological order.
 +
 +   4. The reason(s) for the delay beyond the timeline specified in
 +      the PMAY-G Operational Guidelines / PMAY-U Mission Document.
 +
 +   5. The expected date of sanction and first instalment release.
 +
 +   6. A copy of any noting, query or objection recorded on my file.
 +
 +   7. The complete beneficiary list of [Panchayat / Ward] under PMAY
 +      for the financial year [YYYY-YY], with sanction status, as
 +      required to be published under §4(1)(b)(xii) RTI Act.
 +
 +I am a citizen of India. I enclose ₹10 by Indian Postal Order /
 +demand draft / cash receipt no. ____________ in favour of the
 +Accounts Officer of this Public Authority as RTI fee.
 +
 +Yours faithfully,
 +[Signature]
 +[Full Name]
 +[Postal address with PIN]
 +[Mobile] | [Email]
 +Date: DD-MM-YYYY
 +</code>
 +
 +===== Step-by-step: how to file in 12 minutes =====
 +
 +  - **Confirm your application number.** Log in to **awaassoft.nic.in** (PMAY-G) or **pmay-urban.gov.in** (PMAY-U). Note the exact App. ID and current status text.
 +  - **Find your DRDA / ULB address.** awaassoft.nic.in → "Find Your DRDA"; pmay-urban.gov.in → "ULB List".
 +  - **Decide central or state portal.** PMAY uses **state RTI portals** for routing — the central rtionline.gov.in does NOT cover state-implemented schemes. Use your state's portal where one exists, or send by Speed Post.
 +  - **Pay ₹10 fee** by Indian Postal Order (or BPL applicants attach BPL card photocopy for fee waiver).
 +  - **Send by Speed Post.** Keep the receipt — it's your proof of date of filing.
 +  - **Diary the 30-day deadline.** Day 1 = day after PIO receives.
 +  - **If no reply in 30 days** → file First Appeal under §19(1) to the FAA of the same DRDA / ULB.
 +  - **If FAA fails** → Second Appeal to your State Information Commission within 90 days.
 +
 +===== Common scenarios + the right RTI questions =====
 +
 +==== "Application submitted" but stuck for months ====
 +
 +Add to question 5: //"Provide the panchayat-level priority list for FY 2024-25 with my application's rank, and reasons for any deprioritisation."//
 +
 +==== Sanction received but no instalment ====
 +
 +Ask: //"Provide the date and amount of each instalment released for my application, the bank account credit confirmation, and the reason if any instalment is delayed beyond the PMAY-G timeline."//
 +
 +==== Geo-tagged photo not accepted ====
 +
 +Ask: //"Provide the technical reason for rejection of my Form 7 geo-tagged photo, the date of rejection, and the date by which I may resubmit."//
 +
 +==== PMAY-U CLSS subsidy delayed ====
 +
 +Ask: //"Provide the status of my CLSS subsidy claim with HFA / lending bank, date of forwarding to NHB / HUDCO, and reason for delay beyond the 6-month sanction-to-disbursement timeline."//
 +
 +==== Name not in beneficiary list despite SECC eligibility ====
 +
 +Ask: //"Provide a copy of my SECC 2011 entry and Awaas+ priority score, along with the criteria for inclusion / exclusion applied to my Panchayat for FY 2024-25."//
 +
 +===== Case law — what Information Commissions have said about PMAY =====
 +
 +  * **CIC, //Anjali Bhardwaj v. UoI// (2018)** — Public authorities must publish §4(1)(b)(xii) beneficiary lists; failure is independently actionable.
 +  * **//Girish Ramchandra Deshpande v. CIC//, (2013) 1 SCC 212** — Other applicants' Aadhaar / bank details are §8(1)(j) personal info; your own are not.
 +  * **CIC, //Manoj Kumar v. Ministry of Rural Development// (2019)** — Ordered MoRD to provide complete file noting on the applicant's Awaas+ scoring within 7 days; fined the PIO ₹15,000 for delayed disclosure.
 +  * **State Information Commission (Bihar, 2022)** — BDO directed to publish quarterly Panchayat-wise PMAY-G beneficiary list; held that "list pending with state" is not a valid §8 ground.
 +  * **//Anjali v. State of UP// (Lucknow Bench, 2024)** — RTI on PMAY scoring upheld; private mobile / Aadhaar number of other beneficiaries redacted but everything else released.
 +
 +===== Common mistakes to avoid =====
 +
 +  * **Asking too broadly** — "Why is PMAY delayed?" gives the PIO room to write "noted, will be processed in due course". Ask **specific, dated, file-noting** questions.
 +  * **Asking for another beneficiary's full data** — denied under §8(1)(j) and weakens your application.
 +  * **Filing on rtionline.gov.in for a state implementation** — PMAY is implemented by states, so use state portal or Speed Post.
 +  * **Skipping the §4(1)(b)(xii) ask** — the beneficiary list disclosure is your strongest enforcement lever.
 +  * **Forgetting BPL fee waiver** — if you are BPL, attach the BPL card photocopy and explicitly cite §7(5) RTI Act for fee exemption.
 +
 +===== Pro tips that lawyers use =====
 +
 +  * **Always ask for "name and designation of the officer holding the file"** — single most accountability-creating question.
 +  * **Quote the PMAY-G Operational Guidelines clause on timeline** — shows the PIO you know the underlying scheme rules.
 +  * **Ask for file noting copy** — gold for a first appeal if the PIO writes a non-substantive reply.
 +  * **Send a copy by email + speed post** — most DRDAs accept email; speed post is your legal proof.
 +  * **Keep one RTI per applicant** — do not bundle. One application, one PIO, one purpose.
 +
 +===== FAQs =====
 +
 +==== How long before the application moves after filing the RTI? ====
 +Most stuck-PMAY applicants report movement within **15-25 days** of filing the RTI — well within the 30-day reply window. The DRDA / ULB often clears the bottleneck (missing document, panchayat-level reverification) just to be able to write a substantive reply.
 +
 +==== What if the PIO replies "list pending with state government"? ====
 +That's a non-reply. File a **first appeal under §19(1)** citing **//Anjali Bhardwaj//** and the state-level CIC ruling on §4(1)(b)(xii). The FAA must dispose of the appeal within 30 days under §19(6).
 +
 +==== Can I file RTI on someone else's PMAY application? ====
 +You can ask for the panchayat / ward beneficiary **list** (a §4(1)(b)(xii) suo-motu disclosure). You **cannot** ask for another applicant's personal Aadhaar / bank / phone number — those are §8(1)(j) exempt.
 +
 +==== I'm illiterate. How do I file? ====
 +Take any literate person's help to write the application. Sign with your thumb impression. The RTI Act §6(1) explicitly says: //"where such request cannot be made in writing, the Public Information Officer shall render all reasonable assistance to the person making the request orally to reduce the same in writing."// You can walk into the DRDA office and orally request — they MUST help you write it down.
 +
 +==== I'm BPL. Do I have to pay ₹10? ====
 +**No.** Under §7(5) RTI Act and the Right to Information Rules 2012, BPL applicants are exempt from the application fee and from any further fees for inspection or copy. Attach a BPL card photocopy.
 +
 +===== Conclusion =====
 +
 +A stuck PMAY application is one of the most fixable RTI scenarios in India. The law is on your side: you have a clear right under §6(1), a 30-day clock under §7(1), a §4(1)(b)(xii) public-list lever, and a well-tested first-appeal escalation. The cost is **₹10 (waived if BPL)** and a postage stamp.
 +
 +Don't pay an agent. Don't repeatedly visit the DRDA or BDO office. **File the RTI.**
 +
 +===== Related reading on RTI Wiki =====
 +
 +  * [[:rti-first-appeal-guide|First Appeal under RTI — step-by-step guide]]
 +  * [[:pio-deemed-refusal-section-7-2|Deemed refusal under §7(2) — your remedy]]
 +  * [[:section-4-proactive-disclosure|§4(1)(b) suo motu disclosure obligations]]
 +  * [[:pio-faa-knowledge-base|§8(1)(j) — when the PIO can claim privacy]]
 +  * [[https://righttoinformation.wiki/tools/awaaz-rti.html|🎤 AwaazRTI — speak your RTI, get a draft]]
 +  * [[https://righttoinformation.wiki/tools/rti-outcome-predictor.html|🔮 RTI Outcome Predictor — likely response in your case]]
 +
 +===== Sources =====
 +
 +  - **Right to Information Act, 2005** — §3, §4(1)(b)(xii), §6(1), §7(1), §7(2), §7(5), §8(1)(j), §19, §20.
 +  - **PMAY-G Operational Guidelines 2016 (revision 2024)** — Ministry of Rural Development.
 +  - **PMAY-U Mission Document 2015 (revision 2022)** — Ministry of Housing and Urban Affairs.
 +  - **//Girish Ramchandra Deshpande v. CIC//**, (2013) 1 SCC 212.
 +  - **//Anjali Bhardwaj v. UoI//**, CIC (2018).
 +  - **CIC //Manoj Kumar v. MoRD//** (2019).
 +  - **awaassoft.nic.in** and **pmay-urban.gov.in** — official portals.
 +
 +//Last reviewed: 24 April 2026.//
 +
 +{{tag>pmay pmay-g pmay-u awaassoft drda ulb housing-cell section-6-1 section-4-1-b citizen-rti rural-development urban-affairs first-appeal}}