Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
+{{htmlmetatags>metatag-keywords=(pio handbook, pio reply guide, faa handbook, public information officer guide, first appellate authority, pio rti rules)
+metatag-description=(PIO/FAA officer's handbook — the complete reference (2026) - verified citizen guide on RTI Wiki, India's independent Right to Information reference. Updated 2026.)}}
+====== PIO/FAA officer's handbook — the complete reference (2026) ======
+{{page>snippets:dpdp-banner}}
+<WRAP info>**The lead.** A Public Information Officer (PIO) carries personal liability under §20 of the RTI Act. A wrong refusal can mean ₹250/day (up to ₹25,000) deducted from your salary. A First Appellate Authority (FAA) is the first independent reviewer of a PIO decision. This handbook covers everything both roles need to know — duties, deadlines, exemptions, appeal procedures, and the case-law that has shaped each.</WRAP>
+===== The PIO role =====
+Every public authority must designate a PIO (Public Information Officer) under §5(1) of the RTI Act. The PIO is the single point of contact for citizens seeking information. Duties:
+  - **Receive** the application and acknowledge it
+  - **Decide** within 30 days (48 hours for life/liberty)
+  - **Reply** with the requested information OR a reasoned rejection citing a specific §8 sub-clause
+  - **Transfer** under §6(3) within 5 days if the information is held by a different PA
+  - **Consult** third parties under §11 if information concerns them
+  - **Respond to First Appeal** by helping the FAA review
+  - **Respond to Second Appeal** at the CIC/SIC stage with documentary support
+===== The 10 §8 exemptions — when each applies =====
+| § | Exemption | Practical scope |
+| 8(1)(a) | Sovereignty, integrity, security | Defence, intelligence, foreign relations |
+| 8(1)(b) | Court-prohibited disclosure | Sub judice matters |
+| 8(1)(c) | Parliamentary privilege | Information that breaches privilege |
+| 8(1)(d) | Commercial confidence | Trade secrets — see [[:pio-section-8-1-d-commercial-confidence|deep guide]] |
+| 8(1)(e) | Fiduciary relationship | Bank-customer, examiner-evaluator — see [[:pio-section-8-1-e-fiduciary|guide]] |
+| 8(1)(f) | Foreign government | Information received in confidence |
+| 8(1)(g) | Endangering source/safety | Informant identity, witness safety |
+| 8(1)(h) | Impede investigation | Live investigations only — see [[:pio-section-8-1-i-cabinet-papers|guide]] |
+| 8(1)(i) | Cabinet papers | Until decision is taken — see [[:pio-section-8-1-i-cabinet-papers|guide]] |
+| 8(1)(j) | Personal information | Post-DPDP §44(3) — see [[:pio-section-8-1-j-framework|critical guide]] |
+**Public-interest override**: Even where a §8 exemption applies, the PIO must disclose if the **larger public interest** outweighs the harm. This is a discretionary judgment — and it is the most-litigated test in RTI law.
+===== The FAA role =====
+The First Appellate Authority is typically an officer **one rung above** the PIO in the same public authority. The FAA hears appeals against:
+  * No reply within 30 days
+  * Reply that is incomplete or evasive
+  * Refusal under a §8 exemption that the appellant disputes
+  * Excessive fee charged
+**FAA disposal timeline**: 30 days from filing, extendable by 15 days with written reasons (§19(6)). Beyond 45 days, the appellant can file Second Appeal directly.
+The FAA must give a **reasoned, speaking order** — see [[:case-database-pillar|Bhagat Singh v. CIC (Del HC 2007)]]. Non-speaking orders are routinely quashed by the CIC.
+===== Penalty risk under §20 =====
+The Commission can impose **₹250/day (max ₹25,000)** on a PIO who:
+  * Refuses to receive an application
+  * Fails to provide information without reasonable cause
+  * Knowingly gives incorrect, incomplete or misleading information
+  * Destroys information sought
+  * Obstructs the disclosure
+In **2025**, CIC imposed penalties on 612 PIOs (CIC Annual Report 2024-25). Reading [[:case-database-pillar|recent §20 orders]] is the best inoculation.
+===== The 25-article PIO/FAA cluster =====
+Cluster 1 — **Foundations**:
+  * [[:pio-faa-knowledge-base|Knowledge base hub]]
+  * [[:pio-rti-reply-guide|How to reply to an RTI properly]]
+  * [[:pio-recruitment-playbook|PIO recruitment & training]]
+Cluster 2 — **Section 8 deep dives**:
+  * [[:pio-section-8-1-d-commercial-confidence|§8(1)(d) — commercial confidence]]
+  * [[:pio-section-8-1-e-fiduciary|§8(1)(e) — fiduciary]]
+  * [[:pio-section-8-1-i-cabinet-papers|§8(1)(i) — Cabinet papers]]
+  * [[:pio-section-8-1-j-framework|§8(1)(j) — personal info, post-DPDP]]
+Cluster 3 — **PIO procedure**:
+  * [[:pio-speaking-replies|Why speaking replies matter]]
+  * [[:pio-section-7-9-alternative-form|§7(9) alternative form]]
+  * [[:pio-deemed-refusal-section-7-2|Deemed refusal under §7(2)]]
+  * [[:pio-section-6-3-transfer|§6(3) transfer]]
+  * [[:pio-section-10-severability|§10 severance]]
+  * [[:pio-section-11-third-party|§11 third-party consultation]]
+Cluster 4 — **FAA procedure**:
+  * [[:faa-appellate-review-checklist|FAA review checklist]]
+  * [[:faa-privacy-public-interest-balancing|Privacy vs public-interest balancing]]
+  * [[:faa-section-19-8-powers|§19(8) FAA powers]]
+  * [[:faa-first-appeal-timelines|FAA timelines]]
+  * [[:faa-speaking-order-guide|Speaking orders]]
+Cluster 5 — **Case law and practical scenarios**:
+  * [[:pio-supreme-court-rulings|10 SC rulings]] · [[:pio-high-court-rulings|HC rulings]] · [[:pio-citing-case-law|How to cite cases]]
+  * [[:pio-service-records-rti|Service records]] · [[:pio-investigation-rti|Investigation]] · [[:pio-policy-file-noting-rti|File notings]] · [[:pio-banking-financial-rti|Banking RTI]] · [[:pio-tender-contract-rti|Tenders]] · [[:pio-land-housing-rti|Land/housing]] · [[:pio-education-rti|Education]] · [[:pio-health-hospital-rti|Health]] · [[:pio-political-party-rti|Political parties]]
+===== Tools for officers =====
+  * 📬 [[https://righttoinformation.wiki/tools/pio-reply-checker-app.html|PIO Reply Checker — see if your draft is appeal-proof]]
+  * 🔮 [[https://righttoinformation.wiki/tools/rti-outcome-predictor.html|Outcome Predictor — would the CIC uphold this refusal?]]
+  * 🪄 [[https://righttoinformation.wiki/tools/explain-legal-reply.html|Explain Legal Reply — translate jargon to plain language]]
+  * 📅 [[https://righttoinformation.wiki/tools/timeline-calculator-app.html|Timeline Calculator — never miss the 30-day clock]]
+===== Recent shifts (2025-26) =====
+  * [[:blog:dpdp-act-impact-on-rti-section-8-1-j|DPDP §44(3) rewrites §8(1)(j)]] — narrower citizen access, more PIO discretion
+  * [[:blog:10-best-cic-decisions-of-2025|10 best CIC decisions of 2025]] — must-read for working PIOs
+  * [[:blog:supreme-court-rti-rulings-last-12-months|SC last 12 months]] — collegium notes, §24 strict construction
+{REVIEWED}
+{{{{tag>pio faa officer-handbook pillar guide}}}}
+===== 🔗 Related guides =====
+  * [[:guide|Guides — Right to Information Act, 2005]]
+  * [[:pio-faa-knowledge-base|PIO & FAA Knowledge Base — Advanced RTI Decision-Making]]
+  * [[:case-database-pillar|RTI case-law database — 300+ CIC, IC and judicial decisions (2026)]]
+  * [[:citizen-rti-playbook|Citizen RTI playbook — file, escalate, win (2026)]]
+  * [[:city-rti-master-guide|City-by-city RTI guide — 50 cities, every municipal service (2026)]]
+{{tag>pio faa officers handbook pillar 2026}}