Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
+{{htmlmetatags>metatag-keywords=(guide segment audit, rti wiki internal, content audit 2026)
+metatag-description=(Internal audit of every page under /guide/ on RTI Wiki - status, legal risk, SEO/GEO risk, content + link actions, priority. Phase 1 deliverable for the May 2026 segment overhaul.)}}
+====== /guide/ Segment Audit - RTI Wiki (May 2026) ======
+**Phase 1 deliverable.** Crawled at 9 May 2026 by Agent 1 (legal-risk + applicant slice). Source: ''find /home/bighelpers/wiki/data/pages/guide -type f -name "*.txt"''. Live status checked via curl on righttoinformation.wiki. The 60+ /guide/sample/ RTI form pages are itemised at the bottom under a single bulk row; each renders 200 OK with the standard {{htmlmetatags}} frontmatter and a 1-page sample template.
+**Status vocab:** Keep and polish / Rewrite / Merge / Redirect / Expand / Fix only.
+**Legal risk:** High / Medium / Low / None.
+**Priority:** P0 (legal-risk + visible bugs), P1 (SEO depth + duplicate-canonical), P2 (cosmetic + sample pages).
+===== Audit table =====
+| URL | Page type | Current title | Status | Legal risk | SEO risk | GEO risk | Content action | Link action | Priority |
+| /guide | Hub root | (no source - namespace landing) | Expand | Low | High | High | Agent 2 - write canonical hub /guide.txt with 4-pillar grid | Add hub-of-hubs links to applicant + officer + FAA + samples | P1 |
+| /guide/applicant | Pillar hub | Guide for applicants - RTI Wiki Citizen Guide 2026 | Keep and polish | Low | Medium | Medium | Agent 2 - refresh internal link grid; trim 2026-04 backups | Re-point fundamental-facts duplicate to canonical | P1 |
+| /guide/applicant/application | Pillar hub | How to file an RTI application - Section 6 procedure 2026 | Keep and polish | Low | Low | Low | Agent 2 - already strong (Apr 2026 rewrite) | Stitch in inspection + who-can-ask after rewrite | P1 |
+| /guide/applicant/application/who-can-ask-information-rti | Legal-rights explainer | Who can ask for information under Right to Information? | Rewrite | High | High | High | Agent 1 - rewrite as "Who Can File RTI in India: Citizen, NRI, OCI, Company, NGO Explained". Current page wrongly implies OCI/PIO can file independently and still references J&K exclusion (deleted by Amendment Act 2019) | Add citizenship-declaration template + Drafter CTA | P0 |
+| /guide/applicant/application/procedure-for-inspection-under-rti | Procedure deep-dive | RTI Inspection of Records - Citizen Rights & PIO Playbook 2026 | Rewrite | High | Medium | Medium | Agent 1 - fix Rs 5 per 15 minutes fee error (correct: Rs 5 per subsequent hour); restructure with direct-answer + 6+ FAQ H3 + state-variation note | Add Drafter CTA + state-rules link | P0 |
+| /guide/applicant/application/where-you-cannot-apply-rti | Legal-exemption explainer | Where You cannot get Information | Rewrite | High | High | High | Agent 1 - rewrite as "Section 24 RTI: Exempt Organisations, Intelligence Agencies, Corruption and Human Rights Exceptions". Current is a bare statute paste with no citizen guidance and no corruption/HR drafting template | Add CIC-approval template + state-list caveat | P0 |
+| /guide/applicant/application/how-fill-rti-application-form | How-to | How to Fill an RTI Application Form - 2026 Citizen Guide | Keep and polish | Medium | Low | Low | Agent 2 - already strong (Apr 2026 rewrite) | Cross-link to who-can-ask (P0 rewrite) | P2 |
+| /guide/applicant/application/how-to-locate-public-information-officer | How-to | How to locate Public Information Officer under RTI | Expand | Low | High | High | Agent 3 - currently 37 lines, no FAQ, no state-portal table | Add CPIO directory + 5 state portals | P1 |
+| /guide/applicant/application/information-free-of-cost | Procedure | When to supply information free of Cost? | Rewrite | Medium | High | High | Agent 3 - currently 39 lines; expand to Section 7(5) BPL + Section 7(6) deemed-free + Section 6 fee-only-by-rule | Add fee-table template | P1 |
+| /guide/applicant/application/penality-provisions-pio | Legal procedure | What are the Penalty and Compensation | Rewrite | Medium | High | Medium | Agent 3 - re-cast as Section 20 penalty + Section 19(8)(b) compensation guide | Cross-link to second-appeal/start | P1 |
+| /guide/applicant/first-appeal | Pillar | How to file a First Appeal under §19(1) of the RTI Act | Keep and polish | Medium | Low | Low | Agent 2 - already strong (Apr 2026 rewrite) | None | P2 |
+| /guide/applicant/first-appeal/faa | Procedure deep-dive | First Appeal under RTI - §19(1) procedure + online routes (2026) | Keep and polish | Low | Low | Low | Agent 2 - strong | None | P2 |
+| /guide/applicant/second-appeal | Canonical pillar (DUPLICATE WITH /start) | Second Appeal - RTI Wiki Citizen Guide 2026 | Rewrite | High | High | High | Agent 1 - rewrite as "RTI Second Appeal under Section 19(3): CIC and SIC Filing Guide 2026". Has visible ''<fs x-large>'' inline-CSS clutter, no FAQ, em-dash trap, '''' artefacts | Canonicalise to this URL; redirect /start | P0 |
+| /guide/applicant/second-appeal/start | Duplicate canonical | RTI Second Appeal - Section 19(3) Citizen Guide | Redirect | High | High | High | Agent 2 - page is the better-written duplicate; merge content into /second-appeal then convert /start to a one-line ''[[:guide:applicant:second-appeal|Redirected]]'' stub | Sitewide grep + replace ''second-appeal:start'' with ''second-appeal'' | P0 |
+| /guide/applicant/second-appeal/cic | Procedure deep-dive | How to File Second Appeal under RTI - CIC Practical Guide 2026 | Keep and polish | Medium | Low | Low | Agent 2 - strong; has the URL-italic trap on cic.gov.in line | Run url-italic grep fix | P1 |
+| /guide/applicant/second-appeal/complaint | Legal-rights explainer | How to file a Complaint to CIC | Rewrite | High | High | High | Agent 1 - rewrite as "Section 18 Complaint vs Section 19 Second Appeal under RTI: Which One Should You File?". Current uses ''<fs 130%>'' / ''<fs larger>'' inline CSS, has H1-as-H2 issue (multiple ====== blocks), no FAQ | Add decision-tree yellow box + Drafter CTA | P0 |
+| /guide/applicant/fundamental-facts | Pillar overview | Fundamental facts every RTI applicant should know | Keep and polish | Low | Medium | Medium | Agent 2 - strong (May 2026 rewrite) | Decide canonical between this + fundamental-facts-about-rti | P1 |
+| /guide/applicant/fundamental-facts-about-rti | Duplicate of above | What is Right to Information - RTI Wiki Citizen Guide 2026 | Merge | Low | High | High | Agent 2 - both pages target same intent; pick canonical, redirect the other | DokuWiki redirect via plugin or stub page | P1 |
+| /guide/applicant/time-limit-under-rti | Procedure | Time Limits under RTI Act 2005 - 30 / 48-hour / 90-day Rules | Expand | Low | High | High | Agent 3 - only 47 lines; add deadline-calculator infographic + per-state variations | Cross-link to inspection rewrite | P1 |
+| /guide/guidelines-for-public-authority | Officer-side pillar | Guidelines for Public Authority | Rewrite | Medium | High | High | Agent 3 - has visible inline image hooks but old prose, no FAQ | None | P1 |
+| /guide/guidelines-for-public-authority/rti-cell | Officer how-to | RTI Cell - RTI Wiki Citizen Guide 2026 | Expand | Low | High | High | Agent 3 - only 30 lines | Add DoPT 2013 OM cite + ''rti.gov.in'' state-cell directory | P1 |
+| /guide/guidelines-for-public-information-officer | Officer pillar | Guidelines for Public Information Officer | Rewrite | Medium | High | High | Agent 3 - old prose, no FAQ, no Section 5 framework | Add Section 5(1) appointment cite | P1 |
+| /guide/guidelines-for-first-appellate-authority | Officer pillar (FAA) | Guidelines for First Appellate Authority (FAA) under RTI 2026 | Keep and polish | Low | Low | Low | Agent 2/3 - strong (Apr 2026 rewrite) | None | P2 |
+| /guide/applicant/application/sample/* (45 files) | Sample-RTI templates | (per-page) | Keep and polish | Low | Medium | Medium | Agent 3 - bulk-refresh frontmatter + add Drafter CTA at bottom of each | Bulk regex pass for ''//host//'' italic-trap | P2 |
+===== Total pages discovered =====
+  * **Hub + pillar pages:** 8 (/guide root missing as a .txt; namespace fallback in use)
+  * **Applicant procedure pages:** 12
+  * **Officer-side pillar + RTI-cell:** 4
+  * **Sample-RTI templates under /guide/applicant/application/sample/:** 45
+  * **Backup files (non-canonical, ''.bak.*''):** 19 - recommend Agent 2 archive-and-delete pass before Phase 4
+  * **Live HTTP 200:** all 24 audited canonical URLs (curl 9 May 2026)
+===== Status breakdown =====
+  * **Rewrite:** 6 (the 5 Agent 1 owns + ''who-can-ask'', ''procedure-for-inspection'', ''where-you-cannot-apply'', ''second-appeal'', ''second-appeal/complaint'' = 5; plus ''information-free-of-cost'', ''penality-provisions-pio'', ''guidelines-for-public-authority'', ''guidelines-for-public-information-officer'' for Agent 3 = 4. Total 9.)
+  * **Keep and polish:** 7
+  * **Expand:** 4
+  * **Merge:** 1
+  * **Redirect:** 1
+  * **Fix only:** 0
+  * **Sample-template bulk pass:** 45
+===== Top 10 highest-priority items =====
+  - **/guide/applicant/application/who-can-ask-information-rti** - wrong J&K language, OCI/PIO ambiguity is a legal-misinformation risk (P0, Agent 1).
+  - **/guide/applicant/application/procedure-for-inspection-under-rti** - visible Rs 5 per 15 minutes fee error in body (P0, Agent 1).
+  - **/guide/applicant/application/where-you-cannot-apply-rti** - bare statute paste with no citizen guidance for the corruption + human-rights override (P0, Agent 1).
+  - **/guide/applicant/second-appeal** vs **/start** - duplicate canonical hurting both rankings (P0, Agent 1 + Agent 2 redirect).
+  - **/guide/applicant/second-appeal/complaint** - visible ''<fs 130%>'' inline CSS, no FAQ (P0, Agent 1).
+  - **/guide** root - no .txt source; needs Agent 2 hub page.
+  - **/guide/applicant/fundamental-facts** vs **/fundamental-facts-about-rti** - duplicate intent, Agent 2 to merge.
+  - **/guide/guidelines-for-public-authority** + **/guidelines-for-public-information-officer** - both old prose (Agent 3).
+  - **/guide/applicant/application/information-free-of-cost** - only 39 lines, missing Section 7(5)/(6) framework (Agent 3).
+  - **Sitewide URL-italic trap** in /guide/applicant/second-appeal/cic and several samples - Agent 5 sweep.
+===== Cross-cutting issues for other agents =====
+  * **Backup .bak files** in ''/data/pages/guide/'' (19 files dating 2026-04-19 to 2026-05-04) - Agent 2 should archive-and-delete to keep namespace clean.
+  * **/start vs no-/start canonical** - second-appeal has both ''/second-appeal.txt'' and ''/second-appeal/start.txt''. Same pattern may exist for other namespaces; Agent 2 to audit.
+  * **//host.tld// URL italic trap** - confirmed in ''/second-appeal/cic.txt'' (cic.gov.in line). Agent 5 sitewide sweep needed.
+  * **Inline ''<fs x-large>'' / ''<fs 130%>''** - found in /second-appeal.txt and /complaint.txt; Agent 5 should remove all uses (DokuWiki ''<fs>'' renders inline-style spans; not in our design system).
+  * **Pre-DPDP-2025 case-law citations** - //Girish Deshpande// reference style needs to flag the Section 8(1)(j) substitution; Agent 5 schema layer.
+  * **Sample-RTI bulk Drafter CTA** - Agent 3, after rewriting officer pillars, should add the AI RTI Drafter CTA block to all 45 sample/* pages.
+//Last reviewed: 9 May 2026 - RTI Wiki editorial team.//
+{{tag>internal audit guide segment phase-1 2026}}