📱Test our Android app — free beta!Join Beta GroupYou'll receive the install link by email after joining.

Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.


—definitions:first-appeal-vs-complaint [2026/06/03 17:01] (current) – created - external edit 127.0.0.1
Line 1: Line 1:
 +{{htmlmetatags>metatag-keywords=(RTI first appeal vs complaint, RTI complaint CIC, when to file complaint RTI, section 19 vs section 18 RTI, RTI appeal or complaint)
 +metatag-description=(An RTI First Appeal under §19 is for unsatisfactory or missing PIO responses. An RTI Complaint under §18 goes to the Information Commission for conduct issues or public authority failures not tied to a specific application.)
 +metatag-title=(RTI First Appeal vs Complaint — when to use which?)}}
  
 +====== RTI First Appeal vs Complaint — when to use which? ======
 +
 +<WRAP center round tip 95%>
 +**Direct answer:** A First Appeal (§19) challenges a specific [[definitions:pio|PIO]] decision — use it when the PIO refuses, delays, gives partial information, or is [[definitions:deemed-refusal|deemed to have refused]]. A Complaint (§18) goes directly to the Information Commission — use it when the public authority has no PIO, refuses to accept your application, charges an illegal fee, or destroys records.
 +</WRAP>
 +
 +===== In plain English =====
 +
 +The RTI Act provides two distinct remedy tracks:
 +
 +**Track 1 — First Appeal (§19(1)):** This is the normal escalation path after a PIO decision (or non-decision). You file first with the [[definitions:faa|FAA]] (First Appellate Authority — the senior officer within the same department). The FAA has 30-45 days to decide. If you are still unhappy, you file a Second Appeal (§19(3)) with the Information Commission ([[definitions:cic|CIC]] or [[definitions:sic|SIC]]). The sequence is: PIO → FAA → CIC/SIC.
 +
 +**Track 2 — Complaint (§18):** This bypasses the normal PIO-FAA chain and goes directly to the Information Commission (CIC or SIC). Use it when: the public authority refuses to designate a PIO; the PIO refuses to accept your application; the PIO charges a fee higher than prescribed; information that should be published suo motu (§4) is not available; or records have been destroyed.
 +
 +**Example:** Ravi filed an RTI. The PIO refused without giving reasons — Ravi files a First Appeal. Separately, Ravi discovers the department has no designated PIO at all — that is a §18 Complaint directly to the SIC.
 +
 +===== Why it matters for citizens =====
 +
 +  * **Wrong track = wasted time.** Filing a §18 complaint instead of a §19 appeal (or vice versa) can cause delays as the Commission redirects you.
 +  * **§18 gives the Commission broader powers.** On a §18 complaint, the CIC/SIC can inspect documents, require attendance of officers, and impose penalties without the FAA filter.
 +  * **Both tracks allow penalty.** §20 penalty can be imposed in both §19(3) second appeal and §18 complaint proceedings.
 +
 +===== Quick decision guide =====
 +
 +| **Situation** | **Use** |
 +| PIO refused your request | §19(1) First Appeal |
 +| PIO gave partial information | §19(1) First Appeal |
 +| PIO did not reply in 30 days (deemed refusal) | §19(1) First Appeal |
 +| PIO replied but you want more | §19(1) First Appeal |
 +| Department has no designated PIO | §18 Complaint |
 +| PIO refused to accept application | §18 Complaint |
 +| PIO charged excess fee | §18 Complaint |
 +| §4 disclosures not maintained | §18 Complaint |
 +| Records were destroyed | §18 Complaint |
 +
 +===== Related sections of the RTI Act =====
 +
 +  * **§19(1)** — First Appeal to FAA within 30 days of PIO order.
 +  * **§19(3)** — Second Appeal to CIC/SIC within 90 days of FAA order.
 +  * **§18(1)** — Complaint to CIC/SIC for systemic failures.
 +  * **§20** — penalty in both tracks.
 +
 +===== Related tools =====
 +
 +  * [[https://righttoinformation.wiki/tools/first-appeal-app.html|First Appeal Builder]] — auto-drafts your §19(1) First Appeal.
 +  * [[https://righttoinformation.wiki/tools/ai-rti-draft-app.html|AI RTI Drafter]] — drafts the initial §6(1) application.
 +  * [[https://righttoinformation.wiki/tools/timeline-calculator-app.html|Timeline Calculator]] — computes §19(1) and §19(3) deadlines.
 +
 +===== Frequently asked questions =====
 +
 +==== Can I file both a §19 appeal and a §18 complaint simultaneously? ====
 +Generally yes — they address different grievances. You can file a §19 appeal for the PIO's specific decision AND a §18 complaint for systemic issues (e.g., PIO destroyed records). However, the CIC/SIC may consolidate proceedings if they overlap.
 +
 +==== What if the FAA also does not respond? ====
 +If the FAA fails to respond within 30-45 days (§19(6)), that is a deemed refusal at the FAA level. Proceed to Second Appeal (§19(3)) to the Information Commission.
 +
 +==== Is there a fee for filing a First Appeal or Complaint? ====
 +No. There is no fee for filing a §19 First Appeal, §19 Second Appeal, or §18 Complaint. The RTI Act explicitly prohibits charging fees for appeals and complaints.
 +
 +===== Sources =====
 +
 +  * Right to Information Act, 2005 — §§18, 19, 20
 +  * CIC practice directions on complaint categorisation (2025)
 +
 +//Last reviewed: May 2026. Part of the RTI Wiki definitions series.//
 +
 +{{tag>definitions first-appeal complaint rti-act section-19 section-18 2026}}