Differences

This shows you the differences between two versions of the page.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
+{{htmlmetatags>metatag-keywords=(journalists module 03, §8 exemptions and how to defeat them)&metatag-description=(RTI for Journalists — Investigative Filing Course — Module 03: §8 exemptions and how to defeat them. Defeat the most-common refusals on appeal.)}}
+====== Module 03 — §8 exemptions and how to defeat them ======
+{{ :social:auto:journalists-module-03.png?direct&1200 |RTI for Journalists — Investigative Filing Course Module 03}}
+<WRAP center round info 95%>
+**Quick Reply:** RTI for Journalists — Investigative Filing Course — Module 03: §8 exemptions and how to defeat them. Defeat the most-common refusals on appeal.
+</WRAP>
+<WRAP center round info 95%>
+**Goal:** Defeat the most-common refusals on appeal.
+</WRAP>
+**RTI for Journalists — Investigative Filing Course — Module 03: §8 exemptions and how to defeat them. Defeat the most-common refusals on appeal.**
+===== §8(1)(d) — "Commercial confidence, trade secrets, intellectual property" =====
+Most-abused exemption. Defeats:
+  - **Time-bound test**: post-award records are NOT commercial confidence. Tender is over; the bidders' competitive interest is over.
+  - **Public-interest override (§8(2))**: where the contract value is large and public funds are involved, public interest demands disclosure.
+  - **Severability (§10)**: even if part is exempt (e.g. proprietary algorithms), the rest (price, scope, dates) is disclosable.
+Precedent: *Reliance Industries v. CIC* — SC narrowed §8(1)(d) to genuinely competitive information, not all 'business' records.
+===== §8(1)(e) — "Fiduciary relationship" =====
+Defeats:
+  - **Statutory-duty test** (post-March-2026 SC in Patel): records held while doing the authority's job are NOT fiduciary. Only entrusted-trust data is.
+  - **Two-party test**: a fiduciary relationship requires identifiable parties. Generic "public records" don't have one.
+  - **Public-interest override**: especially for regulator records (banks, audit firms, contractors).
+Precedent: *RBI v. Jayantilal Mistry (2015)* — RBI cannot use §8(1)(d) or (e) to shield bank inspection reports.
+===== §8(1)(h) — "Investigation, apprehension, prosecution" =====
+Defeats:
+  - **Named-FIR test** (Kerala SIC Full Bench Jan 2026): generic "investigation" claims are insufficient; PIO must name the FIR/PE.
+  - **Closed-investigation rule**: once the chargesheet is filed or closure report submitted, §8(1)(h) lifts.
+  - **Public-interest override**: for systemic issues (Vyapam, NSE-co-location), public interest in disclosure outweighs the marginal investigation impact.
+Precedent: *Khanapuram Gandaiah* — case diaries to non-parties typically refused, but with closure report disclosable.
+===== §8(1)(j) — "Personal information" =====
+Most cited. Defeats:
+  - **Public-activity test**: salary, qualifications-on-appointment, performance reviews of public servants — disclosable (Karnataka HC 9-Feb-2026).
+  - **Substantial-public-interest test**: even genuinely personal data is disclosable when public interest is overwhelming.
+  - **Severability**: name + designation + post is public; phone/personal address is not. Sever, don't refuse whole.
+  - **DPDP Rules 2026 §4 interplay**: data principal's consent is now a relevant factor — for living individuals, the PIO should at minimum issue §11 notice.
+===== §24 — "Schedule 2 organisations" =====
+R&AW, IB, ED, NIA, etc. listed in Schedule 2 are exempt EXCEPT for "corruption and human rights violations" — that exception is a goldmine.
+Framing: never ask R&AW for general activity. Ask for "investigations into corruption involving R&AW personnel" or "records relating to alleged human rights violations attributed to NIA officers in [district]".
+The §24 proviso gives a 45-day reply window with CIC oversight.
+===== ✅ Quiz =====
+Quiz available from your [[:courses:journalists:app|course dashboard]].
+===== Next =====
+  * [[:courses:journalists:start|← Course overview]]
+  * Next: [[:courses:journalists:final]]
+//Last reviewed: 24 April 2026.//
+{{tag>course journalists module-03}}