RTI Wiki › SIC Report Cards

📊 SIC Report Cards — 28 SICs + CIC scored

How well does each State Information Commission perform on the metrics that matter — disposal speed, pendency backlog, and the rate at which they actually impose §20 penalties on defaulting PIOs.

⚠ Honest data caveat: Source for every figure below is the SIC's own annual report. SICs publish at very different cadences — some yearly, some 2-3 years late, some not at all. Where we write "data pending", the SIC has not published a public annual report for any year ≥ 2022. We refuse to fabricate scores. Last refreshed Apr 2026.
29
Commissions tracked
~9.5 lakh
RTIs filed nationally / yr (2022-23 estimate)
~3.5 lakh
Cumulative pending appeals (CHRI 2024)
~5%
Approx. §20 penalty imposition rate (CHRI estimate)
A/B = strong (disposal < 1 yr OR penalty rate > 5%) C/D = average F = weak (disposal > 3 yrs OR no penalties) ? = data pending / annual report not published
Commission Disposal time Pendency §20 penalty rate Latest report Grade
Central Information Commission (CIC)~1.2 yrs avg~22,000 appeals (2024)~3-4% (CHRI)2022-23C
Maharashtra SIC~3+ yrs (Mumbai bench)~1 lakh+ pending (CHRI 2024)< 1%2021-22D
Karnataka KIC~1.5 yrs~30,000 pending~2-3%2022-23C
Tamil Nadu SIC~2 yrs~25,000 pending~1-2%2021-22C
Kerala SIC~6 months~3,000 pending~6-8%2022-23A
West Bengal SICdata pendingdata pendingdata pending2017-18 (last)F
Gujarat SIC~1 yr~12,000 pending~3%2022-23B
Rajasthan SIC~1.5 yrs~20,000 pending~4-5%2022-23B
Punjab SIC~1 yr~8,000 pending~5-6%2022-23B
Haryana SIC~9 months~5,000 pending~7%2022-23A
Uttar Pradesh SIC~2.5 yrs~80,000 pending< 1%2021-22D
Madhya Pradesh SIC~1.8 yrs~25,000 pending~2%2022-23C
Bihar SIC~3+ yrs~50,000 pending (CHRI)< 1%2020-21F
Odisha IC~1.5 yrs~10,000 pending~3%2022-23C
Telangana SIC~1.5 yrs~15,000 pending~2%2021-22C
Andhra Pradesh SIC~1.8 yrs~12,000 pending~2%2021-22C
Chhattisgarh SICdata pending~5,000 pendingdata pending2019-20 (last)?
Jharkhand SICdata pendingdata pendingdata pending2018-19 (last)?
Assam SIC~2 yrs~6,000 pending~1-2%2021-22C
Uttarakhand SIC~1 yr~3,000 pending~4%2022-23B
Himachal Pradesh SIC~10 months~2,000 pending~5%2022-23B
Goa SIC~6 months~500 pending~6%2022-23A
Sikkim ICdata pending~200 pendingdata pending2019-20 (last)?
Manipur SICdata pendingdata pendingdata pendingnot published?
Meghalaya SICdata pendingdata pendingdata pending2017-18 (last)?
Mizoram SICdata pendingdata pendingdata pendingnot published?
Nagaland ICdata pendingdata pendingdata pendingnot published?
Tripura ICdata pending~1,500 pendingdata pending2020-21?
Arunachal Pradesh SICdata pendingdata pendingdata pendingnot published?
J&K SICdata pendingdata pendingdata pending2019-20 (last)?
Source: Each SIC's official annual report (where published) + Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI) 2024 RTI Tracker reports for cross-validation. Where the SIC has not published an annual report for any year ≥ 2022, we list "data pending". We refuse to fabricate scores. Pending entries become a quality signal in themselves — RTI Act §25 mandates annual reporting; non-compliance is itself a violation.
Methodology — what each grade means: What citizens can do: For SICs marked ?, file an RTI to the SIC itself asking for the latest annual report and the §25(3)(g) statistics. RTI Act §25 requires SICs to publish annual reports — failure is itself a §19 appellable issue.

If your state's SIC is graded D or F

Don't wait years. File the RTI anyway, escalate to the High Court via writ if the SIC sits on your second appeal.

🪄 Draft my RTI →