When a builder delays maintenance and transfer of a residential project — complete guide for homebuyers:
Step 1: The problem. (a) after possession (the builder gives possession — but does not complete the remaining work — like the clubhouse, the swimming pool, the internal roads, the street lights, the street trees), (b) maintenance (the builder continues to maintain the project — and charges a high maintenance fee — but does not provide proper services — like security, housekeeping, lift maintenance, garden maintenance), © transfer (the builder does not transfer the project to the RWA — the Resident Welfare Association — and continues to control the project — and collect maintenance fees — indefinitely), (d) the issue: the homebuyer is stuck — with an incomplete project — poor maintenance — and no transfer to the RWA — and the builder continues to charge.
Step 2: Legal rights of the homebuyer. (a) RERA (the Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016): (i) the builder must complete the project as per the sanctioned plan — and the amenities promised — within the timeline — as per the agreement, (ii) the builder must transfer the project to the RWA — within the timeline — as per the agreement (typically 5 years — or as per the state RERA rules), (iii) the builder must provide proper maintenance — until the transfer to the RWA, (iv) the homebuyer can file a complaint with RERA (for: (a) incomplete amenities, (b) poor maintenance, © non-transfer to the RWA), (b) the Constitution: the right to life (Article 21) includes the right to a safe and habitable environment — and the builder's failure to maintain — violates the right, © the Consumer Protection Act, 2019: the homebuyer is a consumer — and the builder's failure to provide proper maintenance — is a deficiency of service — and the homebuyer can file a consumer complaint.
Step 3: How to file a complaint with RERA. (a) file a complaint with the state RERA authority (e.g., MahaRERA for Maharashtra — UPRERA for UP — TS RERA for Telangana — etc. — on the RERA website — or by post), (b) the complaint should include: (i) the project details (the RERA registration number — the project name — the builder name), (ii) the issue (the incomplete amenities — the poor maintenance — the non-transfer to the RWA — with photos and evidence), (iii) the agreement (the sale agreement — and the maintenance agreement — and the promised amenities), (iv) the relief sought (completion of amenities — proper maintenance — transfer to the RWA — and compensation), © the RERA authority will hear the complaint (and can: (i) order the builder to complete the amenities — within a specified timeline, (ii) order the builder to provide proper maintenance, (iii) order the builder to transfer the project to the RWA, (iv) order the builder to pay compensation — to the homebuyers), (d) the RERA's order is binding on the builder (and can be enforced — through the RERA's enforcement mechanism — or through the court).
Step 4: File RTI. File RTI with the state RERA authority (or the Urban Development Department) asking for: (a) the project status (for [project name] — RERA number [number] — the completion status — the amenities — and the pending work), (b) the maintenance complaints (filed against [builder name] — for [project name] — from [date] to [date] — and the action taken), © the RWA transfer status (for [project name] — whether the builder has transferred the project to the RWA — and the date — and the reasons for non-transfer), (d) the builder's compliance (whether the builder is complying with the RERA order — and the maintenance standards — and the amenities — and the action taken for non-compliance), (e) the occupancy certificate (for [project name] — whether the OC is issued — and the conditions — and the compliance).
Step 5: Form or strengthen the RWA. (a) the RWA is the key (the RWA can take over the maintenance — and the project — from the builder — and can enforce the builder's obligations), (b) register the RWA (under the state's Cooperative Societies Act — or the Societies Registration Act — or the state's Apartment Ownership Act — as applicable), © the RWA can: (i) demand the transfer (from the builder — under the agreement — and under RERA), (ii) file a complaint with RERA (for non-transfer — and for poor maintenance), (iii) take over the maintenance (if the builder does not maintain — the RWA can take over — and collect the maintenance fee — and provide the services), (iv) file a consumer complaint (for deficiency of service — and claim compensation — for the builder's failure to maintain and transfer), (d) the RWA should have a lawyer (to draft the legal notices — and the complaints — and to represent the RWA — in RERA — and in the consumer court).
Step 6: Consumer complaint. (a) file a consumer complaint (in the Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission — District, State, or National — depending on the claim amount), (b) the complaint should include: (i) the deficiency (the builder's failure to complete the amenities — and to maintain — and to transfer to the RWA), (ii) the evidence (the sale agreement — the maintenance agreement — the photos — the correspondence — the RERA order — if any), (iii) the relief (completion of amenities — proper maintenance — transfer to the RWA — and compensation — for the mental agony — and the financial loss), © the Commission can: (i) order the builder to complete the amenities, (ii) order the builder to provide proper maintenance, (iii) order the builder to transfer the project to the RWA, (iv) order the builder to pay compensation (Rs 50,000 to Rs 5,00,000 — or more — depending on the loss), (d) Example: A builder in Noida did not complete the clubhouse — and did not transfer the project to the RWA — for 7 years — the RWA filed a complaint with UPRERA — RERA ordered the builder to complete the clubhouse — and to transfer the project to the RWA — within 6 months — and to pay Rs 5,000 per flat per month — as compensation — for the delay — the builder complied — and the RWA took over the maintenance.
Step 7: Practical tips. (a) document everything (take photos of the incomplete amenities — and the poor maintenance — and keep all correspondence — emails, letters, notices — as evidence), (b) form the RWA early (do not wait for the builder to transfer — form the RWA — and start collecting the maintenance fee — and providing the services — to demonstrate that the RWA is capable), © file RTI early (to get the project status — and the RERA compliance — before the builder destroys the evidence), (d) file a joint complaint (with all the homebuyers — through the RWA — for a stronger case — and lower cost per homebuyer), (e) cite RERA (the RERA Act — and the state RERA rules — and the RERA orders — to strengthen the case), (f) cite the Consumer Protection Act (for deficiency of service — and the compensation).